I think making these would be just as much as fun as poking the eye to get the treats out! When you start with pre-made, round, papier mache ornaments the rest is easy. Directions for this creepy cute Halloween party favor are at You Are My Fave.
Fem Manuals shares these adorable squirrels made using papier mache over a paper cup armature. Add cardboard arms and legs, a pompom nose, and a fluffy feather for the tail and you have just about the cutest squirrels I've ever seen!
With a little cardboard, string, and a straw you can make this rocket climbing toy in a jiffy and your kids will think you're a genius! Homemade toys are the best and this tutorial at Pink Stripey Socks is an easy one to get started with.