My Paper Crane shares the cutest vintage-inspired chenille stem witch and she also created a free printable for the face. Easy to make, this would be a fun Halloween party craft or string a bunch together for a garland.
I think making these would be just as much as fun as poking the eye to get the treats out! When you start with pre-made, round, papier mache ornaments the rest is easy. Directions for this creepy cute Halloween party favor are at You Are My Fave.